Sunday, December 4, 2011

Why I'm a Feminist and Why You Should Be One Too




One of the things that freaks me out is that, in this day and age, some people are still shocked and disapproving when I say that I’m a feminist: “Seriously, do you hate men that much that you feel the need to be a feminist?” they ask. No, actually I don’t hate men at all. In fact, I know some very nice men and we’re good friends, lovers, and colleagues, thank you very much. The idea that to be a feminist you must therefore hate men is not the only stereotype about feminists that exists; unfortunately, we are often seen as bored housewives with nothing better to do, or angry, lazy women who couldn’t “hack it” in the world, and of course, the bitter, frigid CEO and ice queen.


I’m not a housewife (and I’m certainly not bored with my life—I moved to South Korea for kicks and giggles, people), I know I can hack it in the world because I have two degrees and a good job, oh and while I may not be a CEO, I’m most assuredly NOT frigid (and there are several people who can confirm that story).


But just as worrisome as the people who want to know why I’m a feminist, are the people who proclaim, “I’m not a feminist!” I know this sounds crazy hypocritical and judgmental, because here I am crying out, “I’m a feminist” and shouldn’t people be allowed to not be feminists? Well, yes they should because that’s called freedom, but how could anyone not be a feminist?


Stay with me, because we’ll come back to the question in a minute.


I recently read this blog post by famed lifestyle blogger, C.Jane. While I personally don’t really care for the blog, I also don’t think about it that much because it doesn’t really seem worth it and I’ve only read a few posts, however this particular post stood out when a friend showed it to me. So go on, read it. I’ll wait.


You back? Ok, for those of you that didn’t feel like skipping over to her blog, here is a one-sentence summary. C. Jane is not a feminist because she feels that true equality won’t really do anything for her, and she feels like she already has everything she needs.


Ok, while I personally think people should ALWAYS desire equality, I’m not going to lay into her for that viewpoint (as ridiculous as I think it is) she’s entitled to it. No, my bigger issue with that post is how incredibly selfish it is. That’s nice that she feels her life is so great that equality isn’t going to do much for HER, but what about all the other people in the world (and I do mean people—feminism believes in securing emancipation and equality for all) for whom equality would benefit?


So again, it’s nice that C. Jane’s happy little life is so great that she doesn’t need equality, but it’s not nice for all the people that her statement ignores who don’t have equality.


To whit, one in four women (specifically college-aged) are sexually assaulted in the United States. Similarly, and probably under-reported, is the statistic that one in seven men are sexually assaulted in the United States.


I’d like to live in a world where sexual assault wasn’t so prevalent, and I’d like for it to be ok for victims to report that they were attacked without being branded by a stigma (“slut” for girls, “wimp” for boys). Yeah, I think I’d like for my kids too.


But let us cast our net even further, let us consider the dire (and I do mean dire) circumstances of women in the Democratic Republic of Congo. There, over 12% of women have been raped; statistics have reported that in the DR Congo, 48 women are raped every hour. Thousands suffer from HIV/AIDS, thousands have lost children and family, and few will ever be able to exercise their right to education.


Bet the people the DR Congo would like some equality.


Let’s head north now to Saudi Arabia, where, if you are a woman you may not drive; a man MUST have guardianship over you for your entire life. Now, whether that man is your father, husband, uncle, or even your son is unimportant.


Also, in Saudi Arabia as a woman, should you disagree with any of the policies relating to your life, you will then be publicly flawed or imprisoned. If you are raped, you, the victim, could be imprisoned, or again flogged. Hell, you might even be forced to marry your attacker.


If you live in Saudi Arabia (and are a woman) you might even have to walk around with your “tempting eyes” covered so as not to sexually arouse some poor, innocent man in the street, and thereby force him to rape you (an argument, which shamefully, mirrors our own western logic of, “she was dressed inappropriately, so therefore she was asking for it” and which can even be seen in this ridiculous video about Christian women in bikinis).


I bet some of those women in Saudi Arabia would like equality, and personally, I think it would be pretty cool if those women could be raised in an environment where they would learn that rape isn’t their fault (The Handmaid’s Tale, anyone?).


Let’s continue on though, maybe there are other countries where women would like some equality?

How about India where, although illegal, child brides are still forced to marry men ten times their age (no, my math is not wrong: five times 10 equals 50, which is an actual age difference between spouses that does happen in India).


Should we continue? I mean, we could all over the world and find sex trafficking, child prostitution, torture, and pretty much every other evil thing that you can do to another person.


This is why I’m a feminist, because I don’t just want equality for me, I want other women and men to be able to live according to the dictates of their conscious and without fear of violence and repression. I want women to be able to enjoy and own their own sexuality. I want women to be able to own their bodies. I want children to be able to enjoy their childhood without being forced into marriage. I want women to enjoy the rights of education, property and independence.


This is why you should be a feminist too, not just for yourself, but also for your children, for your sisters across the world who are disregarded, abused, maimed, killed, and reduced to second-class citizens because of a difference in their anatomy.


This is why I’m a feminist and this is why you should be one too.

Friday, December 2, 2011

In the News

Hello, dear readers, and welcome back to Not Another Wave's "in the news" posts! This week we've got quite a few stories to go over as usual; less usual, perhaps, is the way this week's stories tended to categorize themselves based on subject material or vapidity of the original reporters. Ready? Here we go!

Our first category this week, "Fucking DUH!," is also entirely populated by articles from Britain's Daily Mail (I'd say I should stop looking at the DM, but there's always something there to consider or argue with). The first "DUH" article is one that yet again parades social research results as something novel; this time, that women are better multitaskers than men. When you look at the research, the results are stunningly obvious: cis women with cis male partners often wind up carrying a greater workload at home and at the office, probably at least in part due to the continued expectation that cis women make home and hearth their priority when not at work. Another "DUH" article, also from the DM, reports that children who are abused are more likely to be bullies. REALLY? I had no idea! Why have I even included these things in the news? Mostly because, sadly enough, things like this are still news to people. Though if you had no idea that cruelty to children teaches them to be cruel in return, I'd like to know at what point your cognitive processes stopped evolving.

The next category this week is one I'd like to call "What century IS this?" First up is an article out of a small town in Kentucky, where a tiny church community has decided not to recognize or welcome interracial couples. I'm not sure which part is sadder: that interracial marriages are an issue in the first place, or that the church's decision is the result of a community vote. No, really. People chose this policy. And now that American media has got hold of the story, the community is considering a re-vote. Again, really. I can't bury my face in my palms enough.

The second article for "What century IS this?" also comes out of the U.S., where S. 1253 (the Senate's National Defense Authorization Act) has been written to include a provision permitting the President to use the military to arrest and detain any person believed to have any association with a terrorist organization. This is TERRIFYING. If you're sitting there saying "I don't see the problem," re-check your U.S. history, particularly the 1939-1945 period. We've done this already, and the result was the detention of thousands of Japanese Americans in internment camps for some vague person's sense of security. As a ten-year-old doing a project on the internment camps, I was privileged enough to interview a colleague of my mom who had been interned as a boy. I'd never heard of the internments before, and to this day I remember the sense of abject horror I felt when I learned that we, as a country, had deliberately uprooted, threatened, and starved thousands of people simply because they or their ancestors had come from Asia (yeah, no, the U.S. government didn't try too hard to distinguish between countries). We were fighting the Nazis at the same time, for crying out loud, and denouncing what they were doing to Jewish people. How hypocritical! And now we want to bring this back? Oh HELL no. National security cannot be, and should never be attempted to be, bought by the suppression of a broad category of people. It's inhuman, it's ineffective, and it's disgusting.

Finally, in the "century" category, we've got an article about a woman from Afghanistan who served time in jail for being raped and has been released to marry her rapist. Afghanistan is currently claiming that the marriage portion of this story is by the choice of Gulnaz (the woman's name or alias), which may or may not be true- she gave birth to her rapist's child, and I have no idea what her expectation is for the "proper" thing to do with a child out of wedlock, even one conceived by force- but I'm still wincing over her imprisonment for being a victim. I'll admit that I'm quite ignorant about day-to-day cultural expectations in Afghanistan, and I feel that a quick internet search does a disservice to the complexity of any culture, but I feel like there's something amiss with a government that sees victimhood as a crime.

Our last category today is "Things That Make Me Think." In this group, we find articles that release interesting studies, discuss difficult topics, or are generally fascinating (to me, at least). The first, also from Afghanistan, releases the results of a massive study done in-country to examine maternal mortality. Afghanistan has, for many years, been on the list of countries with terrifyingly high maternal death rates (in 2005, the UN reported a rate of 1,800 mothers dying per 100,000 live births; the U.S. was ranked at 5 per 100,000). This new study, however, suggests that the rate is now below 500 per 100,000 live births- still high, but much better. It also suggests that infant and child mortality is improving as well.

Next up in this category is an article that looks at the disparate impact the U.S. economy's nosedive has had on African American families. I thought this article was worth sharing for the way it focuses on historical factors- for example, the ease African Americans had in finding jobs in the public vs. the private sector during the early 20th century- and their impact on contemporary racial gaps. Race is such a touchy subject in America that finding common ground to discuss racial inequality (and what we can do about it) can be nigh impossible, but I think it's worth trying.

Another interesting article comes out of the BBC in Zimbabwe, where the government is prosecuting gangs of women who apparently roam the countryside in search of men to rape. No, I'm not being facetious. It's unclear what the motive is- current speculation is that there's a ritualistic component in semen collection- but what I wanted to focus on was the victims' experiences with reporting the rapes and pushing for prosecution. Rape is never okay, no matter who does it to whom, and I'm saddened by the pervasive perception that rape is only something that (cis) men can do to (cis) women. This belief appears to be fairly global, too- even the FBI's definition of rape is explicitly gendered ("the carnal knowledge of a female forcibly and against her will").

Finally for this category, the good ol' Daily Mail brings us a vapid- but interesting- piece about young (cis) women going out for the evening. The DM's stance is clear from the beginning: these young adults don't respect themselves and are putting themselves in danger, as well as encouraging sexually predatory behaviour from young (cis) men. While most of the women interviewed for the article are quoted in minimally articulate ways, the underlying question (if you can get past the ditzy writing) is an interesting challenge: why do we blame these women for their behaviour (dressing up for attention, which they say they want) when British and American cultures both teach females, from a very early age, to judge their self-worth based on male attention? How much of Manchester's nightlife is the inevitable telos of a culture that minimizes other ways for women to value themselves? Discuss.

Our last article for today is the reiteration of a story that broke earlier this week when Barney Frank announced his semi-retirement. Much has been made of Rep. Frank's career, both for its longevity and what he's done with it, but I feel that it's important to acknowledge- politics aside- that his unswerving attention to the rights of LGBQ Americans has been hugely important in taking another step towards social equality. It's difficult to envision how the battle against the Defense of Marriage Act will go without such a strong advocate in Congress.

That's the news for this week, folks! Tune in again for more news, commentary, ridicule, and exasperation.

Thursday, December 1, 2011

Archive Thursday: A Letter to the Patriarchy

This guest post by Lux was originally published two years ago.

Dear The Patriarchy,

Hi! How are you? Still putting it about that women have all the real power? Hilarious!

Well, another Fashion Week has been and gone and with it the still-not-getting-old debate about how size zero models are destroying our nations teen girls and whether "large" models can walk properly. Naturally, you like to offer your opinion on the subject, as you do in all things, and I can really see how you are trying to help. That said, I am really not sure that endlessly carping on about how skinny women look "weird" and how you would rather have a "real" woman is actually improving the situation as much as you think it is. It may surprise you to learn, patriarchy, that not all issues about the female body are directly connected to your collective penis. As it transpires, while you get to have a crazy amount of influence in the way we girls see our bodies, you don't actually dictate every aspect of our self image. I know!

The fashion industry cares little about whether you get your rocks off over their models. A huge, vapid, global behemoth with a largely female client base gets to define beauty any way it likes, for better or worse. The way it currently stands, I'm leaning towards worse, but not because you find double-A cups and jutting collar bones to be a bonerkiller. Yeah, sure, you want to do Cristal Renn. Who doesn't? But her story and her success in the fashion world has implications that transcend your groin. And blaming a secret "gay fashion mafia" for making flat chests and slim hips into an ideal body shape is not only daft and hand-waving a whole set of complex societal issues, it also makes you seem like homophobic as well as simply misogynist. Your dazzling resistance to believe that any concept of female attractiveness simply has to be about your desires almost makes me admire the fashion industry. Please do not make me admire the fashion industry, patriarchy!

While we are on the subject of body image, I feel I should point out that eating disorders are a far more complex psychological issue than "wanting to look like Kate Moss", a cliche that never gets old, by the way. Sometimes, it's not about wanting to please you, either, or wanting to conform to some unattainable standard of beauty. You know, the kind perpetuated by the magazines and films you like so much. Sometimes, it's about self-destruction and about control, and this is a state of mind that transcends gender. So when a man admits to this particular self-destructive urge, how about not giving it a funny name like "manorexia" or taking the piss or adding little emasculating comments of your own, as if the stigma of mental illness were not enough. There are other ways of hating your body than punishing yourself at the gym, patriarchy. Or crying yourself to sleep at night wondering how Don Draper makes it all look so easy.

So, patriarchy, I see what you're trying to do for us poor, poor ladies. But this is one time (among thousands) that you should maybe butt out. I know it's hard to accept that sometimes your judgment of our bodies is neither wanted, needed or appreciated, but it's time to realise that your desires don't get a say in everything we do. It's time to move on. Get a hobby maybe. Have you thought about knitting?

Wednesday, November 30, 2011

Ask a Feminist: Gender Stereotypes


Today one of my roommates had a homework assignment that I, for one, find fascinating: gender stereotypes. For this assignment she needed to interview two different individuals and get their take on these issues. After she interviewed me, I asked her to forward her notes, and I'm including them here.


  1. What do you think of the idea that “the more prevalent the stereotype, the more the stereotype reflects reality”?
    1. That makes a lot of sense to me, actually, because reality can reflect stereotype. If a stereotype is really strong then people start to live it out or act it out. They think if they follow it, it’s because they’re just built that way.
  2. Do you think all gender stereotypes are false?  If so, why?  If not, what gender stereotypes do you believe are accurate?
    1. It depends. If you’re asking if any stereotypes are true for everyone, then absolutely not. but if you're asking if some stereotypes are true in general, as a pattern, then absolutely. Some stereotypes reflect general patterns. I don’t think many gender stereotypes are true around the world-- a stereotype that is accurate in one culture may not be true in another.  I think of it in terms of overlapping bell curves, where you'll find a few people in the extreme on either side, but mostly you'll find that men and women are in the overlapping area, which usually incorporates about 90% of each bell curve.
  3. What would you classify as benevolent sexism?
    1. Restricting someone despite your good intentions, and without realizing the way it’s affecting them. For instance, a man might tell a woman she can't be involved in politics because it would demean her, or a woman might tell a man he can't cook or clean because it's not in his nature. It is sexist, and it is a false way of seeing things.  It really is causing damage, and restricting someone, but it’s done in the name of helping them.  it is a way of restricting that is hidden or disguised by the name of benevolence.
  4. What would you classify as hostile sexism?
    1. It's a lot more open in its intent to inflict harm.  You see it more when someone is openly devaluing someone, saying "You don’t have a right to do this," or "I have a right to treat you this way because you are a man or woman."  but I think this can be disguised as benevolent when someone does something harmful and says they’re doing it for your good.
  5. Do you think either benevolent or hostile sexism is worse than the other? Why?
    1. I think they’re different. Hostile can cause more damage and be more painful, but benevolent is hard to fight because if they honestly think they are helping someone then they don’t see the damage.  Benevolent can be really dangerous because it’s hard to get anyone to take you seriously when you’re fighting it, whereas hostile people are more open to helping you fight it.
  6. What do you think some main gender (not sex) differences are?  How are these not stereotypes?
    1. That’s hard. I know there are some generalizations like, women are better at multitasking, and men tend to be better at focusing on one thing and tuning other things out. But I also know that there are a lot of exceptions to these things.  I myself tend to be on the masculine side of how I do things, and I know other women who are as well, and it would be a logical fallacy not to think of them as women just because they have masculine traits.  some women are emotionally clueless and some men are very sensitive.  Sometimes men don’t think things through because they are oversimplifying, and sometimes women see things because they are more roundabout.  Men also tend to be more hierarchical in their communication, and women tend to downplay hierarchy and try to even things out. But again, there are exceptions to everything.
  7. Do you think there are any benefits to gender stereotypes?
    1. No, I think there are benefits to understanding some general differences between men and women so that you can adjust and accommodate different perspectives. I've done some research on how men and women communicate differently, and sometimes we say things that mean one thing to men and different things to women. As a teacher I have found that I have to adjust the way I teach to reach out to men.  Once I learned about how hierarchy changes communication I figured out how to change my teaching methods.  You should never take a generality and assume it to be true, you should do research and see if you need to do some adjusting.

Monday, November 28, 2011

Feminist Question of the Week--Video Share

Last week we shared links to some great (or at least interesting) articles, and it was so much fun that I want to do it again! This week, let's share videos that relate to gender. All videos are welcome, whether scholarly, infuriating, or just plain hilarious.

To get us started, I'm going to share a song from Avenue Q that is always fun and always relevant: Everyone's a Little Bit Racist.

Sunday, November 27, 2011

A Feminist Review: "How to be a Woman"




“Women did not invent dust. The sticky residue that collects on the kettle does not come out of women’s vaginas. It is not oestrogen that covers the dinner plates in tomato sauce, fishfinger crumbs and bits of mash. My uterus did not run upstairs and throw all of the kids’ clothes on the floor and put jam on the banister. And it is not my tits that have skewed the global economy towards domestic work for women” (82).

Was a truer statement ever uttered by a woman? I think not. Welcome to the hilarious, feminist world of Caitlin Moran: British TV presenter, journalist, music lover and writer of the funniest thing I’ve read in about 3 months: How to be a Woman. Moran swears her way (amidst a well-stocked playground of cultural references) to a practical, real-time discussion of the current state of women in the world today.

That little jewel I provided for you up above should be considered a fine representation of the entire tone of her book: one of good logic and slapstick sarcasm.

She starts at the beginning of becoming a woman, literally. Her first chapter is entitled, “I Begin Bleeding!” and deals with the obvious, menstruation. Well, that and pornography, and puberty, and her family, and her unfortunate dog, oh and how she didn’t have any friends growing up in a really poor family with seven kids, sharing a room (and a bed) with a few sisters. In reality though, besides the hilarity of that stuff, she also sets the stage for a discussion about the female journey, the journey to becoming a woman. Every woman has to navigate through similar things, the body, friends, family, and of course, trying to figure out just whom we want to be when we grow up and how being a woman is going to fit into all that.

Subsequent chapters deal with the ever-embarrassing body hair (chapter two, “I Become Furry!”) and most importantly, why she believes women should not be getting Brazilian wax jobs. She makes quite a good case for it, too. Pornography and the infantalization of women has something to do with it in her eyes, and well, after reading her arguments, I think I agree. However, the better part of her argument is what she intends to do about it; she suggests some hygienic trimming, but that in order to be a woman, we should grow a proper muff (her words). That’s right, ladies, let yourself rejoice in an afro-style mound of hair and have a party; oddly enough, it legitimately sounds like a blast!

Lest such a frank image of undesirable hair scare you off from this entertaining and thought-provoking read, her book includes so much more: A brilliant (and spot-on, I think) discussion of stripping, burlesque shows and exercise-based pole dancing classes. Exploring our sexuality as women should be an act of fun, empowerment and creativity for a woman, not part of a dark, sleazy showroom where a man is in control of the situation. How she gets to that conclusion and how it ties in to stripping, burlesque shows and exercise-based pole dancing classes is information that you’ll have to read the book to discover.

The book is filled with even more fun times: the birth of her children; her wedding, “my bridesmaid was a six-foot-two gay man called Charlie, who was wearing silver trousers and a pink cape” (189); fashion; and even an indictment against culture for always asking a women (and only women) when they intend to have children, “You never get asked to ask Marilyn Manson if he’s been hanging around in JoJo Maman Bebe, touching tiny booties and crying” (239). I even learned about a creature called a “womble,” which is apparently a fictional creature meant for a children’s television show or something; I’m not really sure.

Now, that doesn’t mean I agree with everything she says; however, I love that she says everything with no apologies. She is a “strident feminist,” and she believes we should reclaim those words, and she does it firmly, with no shame and no squeamishness, which is to me, exactly what feminists are working for. We’re not out blogging and banging doors to agree with everyone; we’re out there to have differences and assert the individual (even the individual interpretations of feminism), and I admire women who do so with strength and confidence and humor and swearing and British spelling.

And wombles.

Tuesday, November 22, 2011

A Reader's Lament on that Vampire Romance Novel that Just Won't Go Away


Try as I might to ignore it, that vampire romance novel haunts me, whether through acquaintances who praise it for its popularity, friends who want to watch the movies together for a laugh, or fellow intellectuals who share links to interesting discussions. And so, again and again, I find myself begrudgingly entering into a conversation I find increasingly redundant: does that vampire romance novel have any inherent worth? Most people will agree that the franchise can at the very least open up interesting discussions, but really, can't any work provide the impetus for an interesting discussion?

When this book first became popular, I didn't really think about it. I had plenty of friends who either hated it or loved it, but as far as I could tell from the descriptions, it was just a romance novel with beautiful cover art. When I finally decided to read it, that decision stemmed from curiosity, combined with desperation after my flight was unexpectedly delayed and I ran out of reading material at the airport. Plus, some friends had recommended I extend some research I was engrossed in with Wuthering Heights and use the same methods on the vampire romance novel, so I hoped the read would prove pragmatic.

And, okay, I'll confess - I enjoyed it for about 50 pages. I found the premise and the characters intriguing, and my plane ride was much more enjoyable than if I'd been reduced to staring at my hands. But then the book seemed to forget where it was going. We spent about a hundred pages in some sickeningly juvenile fantasy where a boy lies in bed with you but with no intention of trying to have sex and spends hours and hours gazing at you in a field. And the narration treated this as normal behavior. Then the male protagonist turned increasingly controlling, and that, combined with the number of times I had to read about what it felt like to kiss a person who felt like a cold statue, left me giggling. I finished the book in hysterics, occasionally rushing out of my room to share with my roommates a passage that was hilarious for the author's unbridled delusion of teenage lust love.

Despite everything I'd heard against that book, I was shocked by how bad the writing was. I went into it expecting something a step below Harry Potter, and instead I found something about as polished as a Harlequin. As far as I could surmise, the only thing keeping anyone's attention was the sexual tension, and sexual tension alone does not even a decent book make. Still, when I finished the first book, I wondered what  would happen next and even considered finishing the series. But I could not bring myself to slog through that writing, and when I learned that even the female protagonist's sweet younger friend who seemed like a viable romantic partner and a great alternative to a stalker was himself going to turn into a stalker later in the series - well, at that point, I tried to wash my hands of the whole thing.

Yet I've never quite broken away from the discussion that surrounds this particular supernatural romance novel. Why not? Because other people are constantly talking about it, and I find it hard to bite my tongue when I start hearing things like, "You can't say she's a bad writer. You just can't say that, because the book proves otherwise." Thank you, random acquaintances, for begging the question with that one.

But you know what? As cool as I find all the discussions the book opens up, I'm sick of talking about it. I don't want to think about it or talk about or read about it or blog about it. I want to wash it out of my life for once and for all. And so, this post is my cathartic goodbye to all the discussions I'm tired of feeling compelled to engage in. Because you know what? It's really not worth it.

So, book which I shall not name, this blog post is my cathartic farewell. I never loved you, I once hated you, and now I pity you in a distant sort of way. Let's just part ways and pretend we never met.