Tuesday, December 13, 2011

Links of Note

Dear Reader, if this page contains nothing but links, I am probably traveling and far too frantic to get onto blogger. Hope you enjoy the links.

From Spark in Darkness, we have an article about new anti-gay legislation in England, which is eerily similar to old legislation, right down to the name.

From feministe, we have an article about teenagers and the crazy myths about that that turn out to be false.

From Feminist Mormon Housewives, here's an article about Girl Power and Interfaith Friendship (and Prayer).

From Racialicious, we have an article about comics, and how the author had to choose between comics that represent either race or gender.

From Feminist Mormon Housewives, we've also got an article with various links to Mormons in the news. Don't worry, they're not all about Romney and Hunstman.

Then from Jezebel, a really disturbing read: turns out a lot of "sexy magazines" are as mysogynistic as rapists (if not more so). I'd like to know more about how this study was conducted before I try to generalize anything, but either way, the article carries some pretty disturbing implications about the way we view sexuality and violence against women.

Then, we've got some research which compares before and after photoshops and reveals just how fake almost all images of people truly are. Feministe has an interesting discussion about this research.

And, if you're still with me, our good friend Carl the Open-minded Chauvinist (aka Carl the OMC) recently put up a post about modesty, a discussion spurred in large part by some silly, power-hungry ass student employee who found a curvy but properly attired (according to her university's policy) girl attractive and decided to project his guilt onto her by denying her entrance to the testing facility. Ok, so I'm reading between the lines here, but I'm pretty sure the writing between the lines is in flashing, fluorescent lights.

Also, if you go to Carl the OMC's article and scroll down to the post below, you can find me engaged in a debate with him about whether or not the disjunction between his beliefs about women and modesty and his endorsement of the book covers in the post is evidence of The Patriarchy rearing its oh-so-ugly head (remember, LDS readers, I'm talking about a fallen patriarchy in this context).

Monday, December 12, 2011

Feminist Question of the Week: Nudity?

I recently ran across this article about modesty and the objectification of women. The article is pretty short so it shouldn't take too long to read it, but just to summarize, the author feels that the push to cover women often leads to further objectification of women. She basically argues for less clothing as a way to free women from patriarchy.

I find the idea provocative and I have to say that in my experience, setting up a dichotomy where the female body is so sexualized that it must be covered and those that don't cover it are sluts, creates a huge problem for women. In the first instance, it seems that when women are told to cover their bodies because those bodies are too sexual, we therefore perpetuate that idea. Similarly, when women choose to dress "immodestly" they are often branded as too sexual. Basically we've created an intense catch 22 in which women are always hyper-sexual.

So I'm curious fellow feminists and blog readers, what do you think about the issue? Is nudity the answer? Is more clothing going to help? Is it changing our thinking? If it is, how do we do that? Or, am I over-stepping the mark here? Is there really no problem with modesty/women's bodies issues?

Sunday, December 11, 2011

A feminist Review: Three TV Shows

Apparently my immune system is not quite up to the challenge of Korean germs; I’ve been in South Korea for three and a half months and I’ve been sick three times. Unfortunate and time consuming? I think so. Ergo, I have spent a fair amount of time lying in bed, coughing and sniffling, looking for something to do and I of course found that the Internet is just a candy land of free TV. So, despite being in rather exotic locale, I’ve watched a decent amount of TV, hence today’s lovely and informed blog post.


Be excited.


Northern Exposure


This is perhaps an odd choice for a review in 2011 (almost 2012) however, even though this show ran from 1990-1995, it’s still a great TV show in my opinion and it seemed like maybe it was time to rediscover it and share it with you all.


The show is sort of an academic, fairytale for adults; sounds like an odd mix I know, but it’s one that works well thanks to clever writing, great characters and gorgeous scenery.


The show takes place in the small town of Cicely, Alaska (the name Cicely being a tribute to the lovely woman who journeyed there in the early twentieth century with her lesbian lover, Roslyn, where they sought to remake the frontier town into a cultural mecca fashioned after a Paris salon—Franz Kafka even makes a brief appearance). Perhaps because of it’s unique roots, the town features a cast of unconventional characters and themes which we discover through the eyes of Joel Fleishmann, a brilliant young Jewish doctor from New York who must repay the scholarship that Alaska gave him by serving as Cicely’s town doctor for four years.


Granted, Joel hates the town, seeing the petty injuries and colds that he treats as beneath the metropolitan education New York and Columbia medical school offered him. However, the beautiful female pilot, Maggie O’Connell becomes his character foil, as she is his opposite in taste, temperament and belief. Joel is a neurotic doctor from New York who isn’t exactly outdoorsy (almost Woody Allen-esque), while Maggie is the independent offspring of a wealthy couple, yet she strikes out on her in the Alaskan wilderness, becoming Joel’s landlord and often taking care of him.


As a feminist, while I didn’t always love her character, I did often enjoy it and I think she’s an interesting portrayal of a woman, certainly not perfect as a character, but neither is she wholly stereotyped.

Northern Exposure’s surreal episodes are often couched within the framework of an unexpected philosophy, which is usually delivered by Chris, the young radio DJ who shares poetry from Edgar Allen Poe, theory from Nietzsche and the wisdom of Buddha (all of this information was of course obtained during Chris’s years at a juvenile detention center).


The few characters mentioned here are just the tip of the iceberg as more emerge from Cicely’s history, and in the case of the misanthropic, no shoes-wearing, five –star chef Adam and his hypochondriac wife Eve, the surrounding forests (literally).


In the scene I've provided you can see Chris (who is also an artist) waxing customarily eloquent as he shares some of his artwork with the town.




Pan Am


Now this show is one that is actually billed as a feminist show, or at least a show with feminist-based content. I have to say though, that while I think the show does have many redeemable qualities, most of the feminism here feels a little fluffy, a little mainstream.


Obviously the show follows the exploits of a specific Pan Am team, the four stewardesses and main cockpit crew (who are of course, all young and beautiful). It’s also set in the 1960’s, a tribute to the madness that has stemmed from the ever brilliant, Mad Men.


The show focuses mainly on their various romantic adventures, although it does manage to hit on some of the major political concerns of the day: the Berlin wall, JFK, racism and communism.


There is one aspect of the show that I do enjoy though, that it depicts the beginnings of a new lifestyle, of a new type of woman that began to emerge (or re-emerge according to The Feminine Mystique) during this period. All of the women are well educated, speak several languages (which was a requirement to be a Pan Am stewardess originally) and had a burning desire for independence, to move outside of what would have been expected for them.


The opportunity to travel, have your own apartment and live as an adult prior to marriage is a great facet of the show as we see them coming of age.


The show does have its moments though, in one episode, a leering passenger gets handsy with Christina Ricci’s character, actually becoming forceful, and so, in response to his unwanted and violent advances, she pokes him with a large fork. Obviously he threatens to report her and have her fired however, the co-pilot, who discovers what has happened when the passenger complains to him, apologizes to the passenger and promises to ensure that she will be punished. Excited that he seems to have saved her job, he rushes to her and tells her to bring the man a drink as an apology. He’s astounded by her disgust, believing that she should be grateful to him for having saved her job. She refuses to bring the man a drink and tells the co-pilot that all he has done is enabled that man to try the same thing again with a different girl.


I love the point his makes about sexual harassment; just because we can laugh it off doesn’t always mean we should, especially if it allows someone to act that same way towards someone else.



True Blood


I know what you’re thinking, isn’t that the show about vampires on HBO? I’m ashamed, ok. Really ashamed. I don’t watch the Twilight movies and I’m not obsessed with vampires, alright? I was sick for the third time, bored, and a friend had recommended the show and so I watched it….and got hooked.


Stop judging me, alright? You have a guilty pleasure TV show too. Just finish reading the review, ok?


Incidentally, I’m going to stop this review right now and say that this show is definitely for mature audiences only. Pan Am and Northern Exposure can probably only be enjoyed by adults, given their themes and content, but besides some kissing scenes, both shows are pretty appropriate for teens and kids. However, True Blood is intense; the show has violence, nudity, drugs, and a lot of swearing. Don’t watch this show if you’re uncomfortable watching an R rated film, (basically, if you didn’t feel comfortable watching The Departed, you won’t like this show either).


Within the show we find a unique microcosm of small-town Louisiana life where Sookie Stackhouse is a telepathic waitress, living with her grandmother in a world where vampires have “come out of the coffin” so to speak and are now a fact of life (they’re also actively campaigning for civil rights). Personally, I find the storyline involving Sookie and her romantic vampire Bill to be a little cliché, (ok really cliche) but I think that the host of other characters that swim through this town to be a redemptive nature. For instance, Sookie’s best friend Tara has a (for me, relatable) personality of intelligence, anger, and intensity as she sarcastically bullies her way through life; for example, she introduces herself to someone in the first episode saying, “Yeah, isn’t that funny, naming a black girl after a plantation” and then when the man smiles amusingly back at her she snaps, “No, it isn’t cause it means my mother was either stupid or mean.” End of discussion.


The tender and victimized side of Tara emerges though as we see her also taking care of her alcoholic and devoutly religious mother, a role played by Adina Porter, quite possibly the best actress in the show: in many scenes she juxtaposes these two facets of her self with incredible ability. One scene in particular stands out as Tara reaches to grab the alcohol from her mother, causing her to spill it; the woman, heartbreakingly begins to cry and reaches down to suck the last drops that fell on her sweater.


Similarly, Tara’s cousin Lafayette, a drag-queen, cook, road-crew worker, and occasional bad boy who’s masculine (and muscular) portrayal of homosexuality I find provocative. I appreciated the fact that he became a true character, not just a sexual orientation to provide interest for the show. Even Todd Lowe, Zach from Gilmore Girls, plays a surprising role as a gentle soldier suffering from PTSD.


Place all this against a deep southern accent and the hanging moss of Louisiana and you get a show that is easily evocative of an Anne Rice novel. The show also spouts some entertaining writing as the last few episodes of season two had me laughing at loud at the straight-faced sarcasm and blithe mocking commentary of American politics.


If that sort of humor isn’t your cup of tea, perhaps the ridiculous, but completely serious image of the queen vampire forcing Bill (a rather serious and brooding vampire) to play Yahtzee with her and her consorts might be more enticing (and for me thought-provoking, if you could live forever in wealth, even if you were a blood-sucking supernatural being, how would you spend your time)?


The opening sequence as well is one of the best I’ve ever seen as it mirrors the themes of the show: life, death, and the dichotomy between sex and religion (I think the opening sequence has actually won awards, that’s how good it is). I would recommend you google it if you're interested in seeing it, however just as the show is certainly not for kids, neither is the opening sequence as it does parallel the show with some disturbing images and brief flashes of nudity.


While this show might not exactly be a feminist show and does have a tendency to get a little campy and over dramatic, I think it is an interesting show for those concerned with social issues as it does deal with sexism, racism, homophobia, religion, and uh….well, the supernatural.



Friday, December 9, 2011

(super)human rights

Recently, the following video has been running rampant all over the Internet:

I'm going to start by acknowledging how important what Mr. Wahls did is. Speaking up for your family in an articulate manner, especially to a legislative body that is considering whether or not to recognize your family at all, is a challenging thing to do. It takes courage and the belief that what you're doing is more important than how nervous or afraid you might be. Being an ally for any given cause takes a particular kind of courage- the strength to Do The Right Thing- because you've always got the privilege of pretending that an issue doesn't pertain to you. I'll also acknowledge that when a movement is trying to achieve a controversial goal- in this case, the recognition of same-sex marriages- trying to find common, nonthreatening ground is a completely reasonable strategy. The less your opposition can criticize you, the easier it is to get what you want. So using an all-American, high-achieving, White, educated young cis man as a spokesperson for same-sex marriage in a socially conservative state seems very wise and effective.

That being said...

What does that say about our (in this case, Americans') social expectations and categorizations of worthy or unworthy? If it takes someone who's close to perfect to convince people that same-sex marriage isn't the end of existence, then what does that mean for all the parents out there- same-sex or otherwise- whose children aren't close to perfect? Are they failures as parents? Are they the reason the Iowa legislature wasn't willing to recognize same-sex relationships? Are they not permitted to marry? I get the feeling that heterosexual couples raising children will never have to hold their model children up as proof that their relationship is legitimate. In fact, I get the feeling that a heterosexual couple asked to do so would get pretty snarky, particularly since it's a commonly-accepted fact in American heterosexual families that- even when parents are good parents- children can be really screwed up. The underlying message of Mr. Wahls' appearance in the state legislature- not one intended to be communicated by him, I'm sure, but one that Americans tend to generate and receive whenever social controversy comes up- is that same-sex parents have to produce perfect children in order to legitimize their relationship. They can't afford to have messed-up children- in other words, they can't be human parents.

This is a common theme throughout American social movements. The early first-wave feminists of the late 19th and early 20th centuries used the "model spokesperson" tactic by asking that their demonstrators wear perfect clothes and use perfect comportment (besides chaining themselves to buildings, of course) to appeal to the sympathies of the men wielding electoral power. Civil rights activists in the 1950s and 60s were instructed to use passive resistance so as to minimize opponents' opportunities to paint the protestors as violent, dangerous people. Spokespeople for social assistance programs such as Temporary Aid to Needy Families are usually the ones who have managed to make superhuman efforts (living on less-than-minimum wage while raising five academically talented children in the ghetto, for example) to survive. As I said earlier, for the opponents to any of these movements or programs, such representatives are much harder to hate than the ones that can be labeled as "unworthy" in any way (in these examples, in order, unfeminine, violent, or lazy).

The problem is that human rights are rights for a reason. You shouldn't have to be superhuman, uberfeminine, or a living punching bag to feed your family, cast a vote, or be treated like a person. You shouldn't have to be a "model" anything to be assessed as a person or as a parent. Permitting same-sex marriage and parenting, to go back to Mr. Wahls' address, shouldn't be based on whether your children could run a Fortune 500 company immediately after high school. Permitting same-sex marriage and parenting shouldn't be based on anything that's related to the sexes and genders of the people involved. We don't generally assess parenting by whether or not the children are the product of a heterosexual marriage; when we do, we're more concerned with the (gender-neutral) aspects of the marriage such as violence or a high-conflict divorce than whether or not both parties had specific sets of genitalia. And when we assess heterosexual marriage, period, we care about genetics (i.e. "are you first cousins?") more than any other category. It's only with the subgroups that spokespeople must be as nonthreatening as possible.

Part of the point of social movements is that they do threaten the social order because the current social order (minimal enfranchisement, subhuman treatment, a starving family) is unjust. Social movements, by nature, seek to change that. The subterfuge of "this spokesperson is clearly not a threat to us!" is at best simply concealing the reality that a new social order will change the way the "us" category is compelled to treat a given group of people; at worst, it sends the message that the "us" group can use this model spokesperson as the ruler by which all other members of that group will be measured. When our standards are that high, a vast number of people is set up to fail simply because they're not superheroes. By definition, superheroes are extraordinary. How is it in any way fair to judge an entire group of people by their exceptional members?

I genuinely appreciate Mr. Wahls' contributions to getting Iowa to recognize same-sex relationships, and I applaud his parents for raising a successful child (no mean feat!). But I do question why it is we require our downtrodden, our unrecognized, our oppressed to meet extremely high criteria in order to be awarded basic rights and recognition.

Wednesday, December 7, 2011

Oh, How I Wish You Had Asked a Feminist

Today's installment of Ask a Feminist is rather a wistful, melancholy affair. Why? Because recently people have been asking the wrong questions to the wrong people, who give them answers that only reinforce sexist and misogynistic attitudes (and yes, women are quite capable of misogyny). First up, some middle-aged man who apparently thought himself quite clever decided to write into Dear Margo and pretend to ask for advice on understanding the term "Friends with Benefits." Too bad the letter was nothing but a poorly-disguised jibe at loose women. Because the man wasn't really asking what friends with benefits meant. No, he asked Dear Margo when "sluts" had come to be known as "friends with benefits" and where he could find one of these renamed sluts. And Margo, instead of calling him on his self-righteous, sexist, double-standard crap, patted his head and agreed that women who do friends with benefits really are sluts and that it's just a generational gap.

Oh, how I wish the sexist ass  individual had asked a feminist. If he had asked me, for instance, I would have asked how he'd made it to middle age without learning the difference between singulars and plurals. I mean, he seems to think that friends with benefits refers to individual female sluts who lavish their attention on lucky, but oh-so-moral male recipients. Then I'd ask if he knew what the word "friends" meant, or if he really thought gorgeous female strangers would randomly decide to have their wicked way with him, all in the name of "friends with benefits." I mean, he must be super hot to think that's gonna happen. And then, I'd have to end by asking, If these women are sluts by your definition, what does that make the men who seek them? Johns?


But all playing aside, this is just a cut-and-dry case of sexism and double standards, with a bit of arrogant hypocrisy spicing things up.

And second - oh dear, I seem to have lost the link. How about I distract you with a little humor?

And hey, how about watching a Lily Allen music video that critiques defining women by their age and/or relationship statuses?



And if that doesn't work, here's a super fun song from Mika:

Tuesday, December 6, 2011

In Memory


Memorial to the Montreal Massacre, from http://media.mmgdailies.topscms.com
 On this day in 1989, a 25-year-old man named Marc Lépine was angry. He had been rejected yet again from the École Polytechnique, an engineering school in Montreal, and blamed feminist affirmative action for filling "his" slot with less-qualified female students. In the space of about twenty minutes, he went through the school with a semi-automatic rifle and a knife, systematically separating students by sex and shooting or stabbing them. At the end of his rampage, when he turned the gun on himself, Lépine had killed fourteen women. During the shooting, when asked why he was doing this, he answered in French "I am fighting feminists...You're all a bunch of feminists. I hate feminists."

Canada's response to the Montreal Massacre, as it is now known, has been varied. Reluctant to admit that Lépine was specifically targeting women, the Montreal police only acknowledged the sex-based nature of his crimes when his suicide note was released a year later. The federal government designated December 6th as the "National Day of Remembrance and Action on Violence Against Women" in 1991, and the same year a group of men in Ontario started the White Ribbon Campaign. However, some groups have accused feminists in Canada of using the Montreal Massacre as an excuse to promote anti-male agendas, and some radical men's rights groups have glorified the Massacre as "heroic." Sick.
What matters, however, and the reason I'm hijacking our usual posting schedule to spotlight this tragedy, is that the Montreal Massacre highlights the ways in which feminism is still necessary. Nathalie Provost, one of the survivors of the shootings, told Lépine that she and her fellow female classmates weren't necessarily feminists, "just students intent on leading a normal life." Lépine's retort was that women intending to be engineers were feminists. As sick as this will sound, I have to agree with him. Provost and her classmates may not have wanted to march in the streets or agreed with pro-feminist legislation, but sometimes feminism- or any fight for equality- doesn't happen in the realm of public policy. Sometimes the most political of acts is simply asserting your right to attend the program of your choice. Time and time again, we have seen in North American political history how access to education sparks some of the most violent and vile responses from privileged opponents; when a person's right to that education is in question, their decision to attend becomes a form of protest against the hatred that would keep them from it. It doesn't have to come from an intention to change the world, but sometimes it does. Lépine's massacre of fourteen students highlights that in an incredibly grotesque and sad way.
This post is written to recognize the tragedy of December 6, 1989, and to ask that all Go Girls everywhere remember that feminism can be small things like going to school or big things like amending the Constitution. Anti-feminism can be equally small, such as a sexist slur on a street corner, or large, such as denying women the right to vote. You can choose to see Lépine's behaviour as that of a crazy person or that of a person hell-bent on sending women back to the Stone Age; it's really up to you. But until people stop targeting each other for belonging to one social category or another, the things we do- small and large- to advance human rights will continue to matter.

Monday, December 5, 2011

Feminist Question of the Week: Where Do Men Fit in Feminism?

Image source: http://feministryangosling.tumblr.com/

This question has been on my mind for awhile, but I've felt unsure about how to address it. On the one hand, I feel like it's an unnecessary question that harks to the fallacious belief that feminists are women and that men can't be part of the movement. But on the other hand, there are some legitimate questions about how feminist men can be full participants in the movement, without reinforcing patriarchy (for my LDS readers, remember - we 're talking about the form of Patriarchy that Hugh Nibley refers to as a fallen patriarchy - one that is about control and power over women, not about partnership and service). So, what are some of the inherent obstacles we need to consider? Well, for one, most research finds that if more than 25% of the people in a discussion are men, the majority of conversation comes from men, and the same phenomenon takes place in a lot of feminist discussions.

Now, some bloggers - like Twisty from iblamethepatriarchy - have gone so far as to discourage men from participating on their websites, but that's obviously something we'd never do here at NAW. A solid portion of our readership is male, and each of our male readers contributes a unique and interesting personal perspective. Plus, how could we ever sacrifice the great discussions between Jeremy and Jon? But the blogs that discourage male voices (as much as I disagree with their policies) do so for a reason: they get sick of a phenomenon known as "mansplaining." What is "mansplaining"? Well, it's a term feminist bloggers use to refer to men who show up and attempt to set all the feminists right, usually prefacing their comments with something along the lines of, "As a man, let me tell you what men think about ______."

Why isn't such a helpful comment appreciated on a feminist blog? Well, generally such comments miss the point. For instance, a couple years ago I wrote a post in defense of feminine styles of communication. A few men showed up and took it upon themselves to explain male communication and encourage women to adapt to male communication patterns. But the whole point of my post was that feminine communication was just as valid as male communication. If I'd written a post about how confusing I found male communication, those responses would have made sense. As things stood, I personally already communicated in a more masculine style, as I had stated in the original post. So, as great as their intentions may have been, those particular male readers were only exacerbating the situation by  making the discussion all about how women should adapt to male needs, and by refusing to listen.

So, with all these issues in mind, let me repeat the question:

Where do men fit in feminism? How can female feminists help male feminists feel welcome, while avoiding some of those obstacles I just listed? And what should a man do if he's new to feminism and wants to join the discussion?